Best pizza I've had in south Florida! Garlic rolls are to die for, ask for the meat sauce and thank me later!

Will be back when we go back into town! Service was the sweetest and super helpful! Food was quality! And ambience looks like a cute pizza parlor! Garlic rolls were a hit! Hot honey pizza was delicious (we had it with no pepperoni!) family size Caesar salad was perfect and so fresh!

The best pizza in South Florida. Hand tossed dough, their own sausage blend and simply fresh ingredients.

Long time favorite, known John since high school now it's almost time for me to retire. Highly recommend this place for the extra wet rolls and pizza.

I love John The Baker. I first came here due to an intense pizza craving and needed a place nearby to satisfy that craving stat! Uber Eats led me the John the Baker and baby let me tell you John and I have been besties ever since. I usually order to go but today was my first time dining in, so I can finally speak on the service. Service is also great! But let me tell you what really keeps me coming back...the rollsssssssss. The garlic rolls are hands down thee best I've ever had anywhere including NYC. Buttery, pillowy, soft, garlicky perfection. What I love most about them is they do not put chopped garlic on the rolls like many places do. They use a housemade garlic oil. So the bread is still intensely garlic tasting but not offensively so. Ladies this means you can still kiss your man even after eating a half dozen by yourself (don't ask me how I know, mind ya business). The pizza is also good. I don't love the pizza nearly as much as the rolls but it's still good pizza. And it's reasonably priced! I haven't yet tried their non-pizza dishes but I def have my eye on the baked ziti. I will be trying that on my next visit.

The reviews did not lie. The garlic knots were buttery and full of flavor. The bacon cheese pizza was served crispy...as we ordered. We are from home of New Haven pizza and this was just as good! Daniel, our waiter, was very friendly and helpful. Head here for a true Italian experience

I've been coming here for years & the quality of their food has never changed. Whether it's a delicious pasta dish, a good ol' chicken parm sub or some mouth watering pizza, you can't go wrong. The ingredients they use are super fresh & if you're dining in or taking out the food is usually prepared within a reasonable time. They run a special on Tuesday's where you can get a large 16" for only $12.99. Considering prices have gone up everywhere, I really think it's reasonable for the quality you get. You won't find a better pie in the area. Service is always good. The employees are friendly & do a good job at managing the crowds. I haven't had many issues with the food, but the few times there were mishaps they've always done a great job at making sure I was satisfied in the end. Good customer service goes a long way & that's another reason why I'll keep coming back. If you have a delicious entrée you might as well end it with some dessert & I highly recommend the cannolis; they're some of the best I've ever had. The sweet ricotta that they're filled with is out of this world. The shells are always the perfect texture which really complete them. Be sure to grab 1... or 5. Life's too short to skip out on dessert!

If you're on the hunt for a place that feels like a comforting hug and dishes out flavor. John the Baker is our go-to for reliable, delicious Italian eats with a side of family warmth. Each dish tastes homemade. Dine-in, takeout, or delivery - they're all about making life easier, and tastier. Don't miss out on their Pasta e Fagioli soup - it's a delicious must-try! And, oh, the garlic rolls are absolutely yummy. On a recent visit, our Chicken Parm sub had a slight burn, but guess what? It was still bursting with flavor! A small glitch won't keep us from returning. John the Baker truly nails the blend of reliability and flavor. Highly recommended!

Best pizza in town. Just ordered two dozen of their famous garlic rolls with baked ziti, chicken and salad. All were hot and ready to eat. Easy restaurant location at Flamingo Rd and Sheridan St. They make togo orders very simple. Lots of locals eat here. Staff is very friendly and a clean place.

Excellent New York style pizza. I've been coming here for 25 years. I am sure that I have written a review. Possibly it was written for a different location. John the Baker is located in the Fresh Market Plaza. It is a small location but they have plenty of seating. The staff are very proficient in dealing with large crowds. They move out the pizza and pasta dishes faster than any Italian place that I know. The food is always hot and the quality is consistent. Don't expect too much as far as decor. It is relatively simple but watching the show between the staff and the pizza makers makes up for any fancy decorations. The place is not quiet. Sometimes it can be hard to hold a descent conversation. Most important, the pizza is great, the meatballs are good and their cannoli are the best. I love that they fill the cannoli to order. Many people love their garlic rolls. While they are good, lately I like a small basket of crusty bread instead. Back when this was located in the Walmart plaza, I had a few of my children's birthday parties at John the Baker. Everyone left happy and they let us bring our own cake and party supplies. This is a family owned place that has a regular following.